Hi,
first rejected for uncentered only.
https://abload.de/img/q33a5409-1grossfertigshfhq.jpg
After appeal I got this:
Here's why your photo was rejected:
- Motive
- Oversharpened
- Personal Message
The Screener left a comment regarding this photo:
"Rejection reason revised, centering acceptable but pole obstructing main gear and bit too oversharpened"
I really would appreciate if the appeal screener only check the first given rejection reasons and don't look for other issues again unless there are very obvious issues like wrong data.
Especially when the reason for the first rejection is cancelled....
Best greetings
Rainer
Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
Re: Appeal Screening cancels rejetion reason but rejects for other new reasons....
Hi Rainier, imo the titles, tail, cockpit windows are a bit OS. The pole is a bit annoying, but that's 50/50 on rejection or not. As for centering, was it originally rejected for high or low?
Re: Appeal Screening cancels rejetion reason but rejects for other new reasons....
I agree with what Preston said above. Although the rejections on the appeal should've been given on the initial rejection. I'm baffled how that was missed on the first screen.
Re: Appeal Screening cancels rejetion reason but rejects for other new reasons....
Centring looks acceptable to me, although my personal preference would be to have it a touch lower (and I'm guessing the screener thought likewise). As for the pole, as far as I know, that will always be an instant rejection here, especially since it was clearly avoidable. The more disturbing issue is indeed how it was missed in initial screening (it's the first thing I saw when I opened the image), but that's one for another debate.....
Karl
Karl
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests