Hi all,
Had this one rejected from the creative team,
https://imgproc.airliners.net/photos/air ... d52c700070
Rejected for Motive with a personal message "Sorry, motive doesn't work."
Seems three screeners took a look with two asking for a second opinion.
Just wanting to confirm that the pilot in view is the reason for the motive rejection.
Thanks
Steve
Moderators: richierich, ua900, PanAm_DC10, hOMSaR
Re: Creative Rejection - Motive
Hey Steve,
The creative queue is screened by the HS only and the procedure is that all of us give a SO and the last one processes the photo (unless a 3-0 vote is achieved, then the 4th HS is not needed). In this case I was the first screener, and remarked that I thought the prop edges looked oversharpened and that I didn't like the motive. With the motive, the pilot is the main issue. It's a guy standing on a wing, leaning forward with his hands near his crotch (I know he's strapping the chute/whatever). But it still doesn't make for a great motive for me. Maybe if he had been in another pose, it would've been different. 2 other HS seemed to agree, making it a majority vote (3-0 in favor of a rejection for it).
Hope that explains the rejection and process a bit.
The creative queue is screened by the HS only and the procedure is that all of us give a SO and the last one processes the photo (unless a 3-0 vote is achieved, then the 4th HS is not needed). In this case I was the first screener, and remarked that I thought the prop edges looked oversharpened and that I didn't like the motive. With the motive, the pilot is the main issue. It's a guy standing on a wing, leaning forward with his hands near his crotch (I know he's strapping the chute/whatever). But it still doesn't make for a great motive for me. Maybe if he had been in another pose, it would've been different. 2 other HS seemed to agree, making it a majority vote (3-0 in favor of a rejection for it).
Hope that explains the rejection and process a bit.
Re: Creative Rejection - Motive
I quite like it, although whether it's actually creative is a subject for conjecture.......
Re: Creative Rejection - Motive
JakTrax wrote:I quite like it, although whether it's actually creative is a subject for conjecture.......
Actually creative... given it was screened by the creative team, and not thrown into the queue with the 'normal' shots, then I guess for a.net it is creative... just not creative enough.
Creative in the real world... not really.
Steve
Re: Creative Rejection - Motive
Just for some variety of opinion, Steve...
It doesn't really work for me. I thought the pilot was zipping up his fly at first....
It doesn't really work for me. I thought the pilot was zipping up his fly at first....
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 18 guests