To be honest , it is not necessary to say this when you appeal a photo. Saying the reasons is enough i think. Even you write things like this Head screeners would not accept it as it indeed has some issues.
I saw in MXP recent uploads a lot of pics absolutely low low quality and with a lot of problem light, soft, blurry etc etc... sometimes also some of my pic was accepted and it had to be rej example:
Regarding to this , i have to say different screener has different standard in screening. They can not have 100% same standard or it is very hard for them to do it. For example, i used to showing some photos in the Forum before i upload them to ask for opinions from other photographers and some Screener and Head Screener will come and give their opinions there. Then i will see some of them give me more reasons to reject and some give less reasons. Well, it depends on screeners.
And some photos that have already accepted to the Database it doesn't mean that they are perfect or no problems with them. Nothing is perfect i have to say so maybe in your standard their photos have some issues should be rejected but in screener's perspective they think it is ok for them to accept.
I signaled a lot of time your screening process problems, especially to add every time different motivation to don't accept a pic
Well , everyone here or every photographers who upload their photos to A.net also spent a lot time to process the problems or issues that they get from the screeners and we are keep fixing them instead of blaming them if i can't fix it anymore or it has been rejected for many times i will consider that it is time to let it go. AND you should undestand that SC and HS also spend lots of time screening our photos and give us explaination and reasosns.Everyone has the same process . Even the screener and HS they have the experience i think. Also i think some of them will get rejected photos now even they are SC or HS now.
I had the same situation to u before. I had uploaded a VS B744 to A.net for many times (More than 6 times) and they rejected me for 6 times , and each time with different reasons some of them get 3 reasons and some of them get 5 reasons. Well, i was getting crazy at that time
. And then i appeal one of them and typed a lot of words to explain the photos and my feelings to the sceener. After appealing , i got the reply isn't accept but Rejected
and also with his personal message and is a long articles there. The HS told me that everyone has this experience and nobody can avoid it . Also said that practise more after rejecting and keep revising them will make them easy.
I think it is reasonable sentence.
Regarding to the photo that you said ,
It is indeed underexposed. IF u don't believe your eyes you can use Histogram to see the exposure. It shows me that it lacks exposure you can check it by yourself.
Also it lacks a bit of contrast not so bad just give a little would be enough.The wings seesm to be a little bit soft i think.
Hope it can help you.